Croatian medical chamber warns candidates have no insight into interview scores
The Croatian Medical Chamber warned that doctors have no insight into the justifications for interview scores and that assigned points are final. Nikola Prpić, President of the HLK Committee for Young Doctors, stated that assigning the same number of points to most candidates in an interview violates the rules because the committee did not individually evaluate the applicants. The case involves a competition for two cardiology specialties at KBC Sestre milosrdnice, announced on September 9, to which 45 applications were received.
Interview scores are final
The HLK warned that doctors have no insight into the justifications for interview scores and that assigned points are final. The candidate previously ranked 34th had 30.60 points and finished second with 60.60 points after the interview.
The competition
The competition for two cardiology specialties at KBC Sestre milosrdnice was announced on September 9. The Specko application, which collects publicly published competition results, reported that the selected candidates were previously ranked 12th and 34th. Both candidates received the maximum of 30 points in the interview, while the first-ranked candidate from the initial list received 1.40 points and finished in fifth place.
The new rule
According to the new rule, which came into effect on September 3, the interview with a five-member committee can bring a maximum of 30 out of 100 points, with each committee member awarding up to six points. Prpić warned that the situation where most applicants received the same number of points in the interview is an example of a rule violation because the committee clearly did not individually evaluate the candidates. However, the HLK does not advocate for reducing the influence of the interview on the final result.
The first-ranked candidate
The first-ranked candidate had 58.89 points and finished with a total of 60.29 points after the interview. Every point awarded in the interview is partially subjective.
Public consultations
During public consultations, the HLK supported the proposal that the interview should account for approximately one-third of the total points because they believe it allows for the differentiation of the best candidates. The HLK does not advocate for reducing the influence of the interview on the final result.
Glossary
- new rule — The new rule came into effect on September 3. It states that the interview with a five-member committee can bring a maximum of 30 out of 100 points. Each committee member can award up to six points.
- five-member committee — The five-member committee is the body that conducts the interview. Each committee member can award up to six points. The committee is responsible for awarding points in the interview.
This article was written with AI assistance from multiple news reports and is reviewed by our editors under our editorial principles. Editorial Standards · Tips & Contact
Comments 0